If you’re about to make your first Operations Director, Finance Director or Head of Commercial appointment, you’ve probably wondered whether you need “executive search” or whether a normal recruitment process will do. This article explains what executive search actually involves, how it differs from standard recruitment, and how to tell whether your hire needs it.
The short answer: executive search is a structured, usually retained process for senior appointments. Rather than advertising and waiting for applications, a search consultant maps the market, approaches the people best suited to the role (most of whom aren’t looking) and runs a rigorous selection process with you. It’s worth using when the hire is senior, newly created, hard to find or high risk if it goes wrong.
Why senior hires are different
A senior hire shapes everything underneath it. The right Operations Director can take a growing business to its next stage; the wrong one can cost a year, a team and a lot of money before anyone admits it isn’t working.
The people you most want for these roles are rarely on job boards. They’re doing well where they are, so an advert reaches a small and often unrepresentative slice of the market. That’s the gap executive search is designed to close.
How executive search works
Most searches follow the same shape:
- A proper brief. Not just the job description, but where the business is heading and what success looks like at six and twelve months.
- Market mapping. Identifying the businesses and individuals with the right experience, including people who haven’t thought about moving.
- Approach and assessment. Confidential conversations to test experience, motivation and fit before anyone reaches you.
- A focused shortlist. Fewer candidates, each one properly assessed and genuinely interested.
- Selection support. Advice on interview stages, assessment and presentations, through to offer and start.
At Eaton Syalon, most searches at this level are retained: we work exclusively with you until the right person is found, rather than racing other agencies to a shortlist.
Executive search vs standard recruitment
The two approaches differ in four main ways:
- Who you reach. Standard recruitment mostly reaches people who are actively looking. Executive search reaches the wider market, including people who aren’t.
- How candidates are found. Standard recruitment relies on adverts, databases and applications. Executive search relies on market mapping and direct approach.
- How it’s paid for. Standard recruitment is usually contingent, paid only when someone is placed. Executive search is usually retained, with a commitment made up front.
- What it’s best for. Standard recruitment suits roles with a healthy pool of candidates. Executive search suits senior, newly created or hard-to-fill roles.
Neither is better in every situation. Plenty of senior hires work well through a strong contingent process, especially when the consultant already knows the right people. The question is how much risk you’re carrying and how hard the right person will be to find.
When does an owner-managed business need executive search?
It’s worth considering when one or more of these is true:
- It’s a first. The first Operations Director or Head of Commercial means there’s no blueprint, so the brief needs as much work as the search.
- The role is newly created. You’re hiring for where the business is going, not replacing who was there before.
- The market is small. The right people are few, and most of them aren’t looking.
- Discretion matters. You can’t advertise because the current post holder doesn’t know yet, or the market would read too much into it.
- Getting it wrong is expensive. In money, momentum or confidence across the team.
Owner-managed businesses often feel the last point most. A first senior hire is a big investment, and the owners are usually the ones who live with the consequences day to day.
What this looks like in practice
A Nottinghamshire manufacturer had grown consistently for five years and had ambitious plans for what came next. To deliver them, the owners created two new senior roles: Operations Director and Head of Commercial. They were the first hires the business had made at that level, and a significant investment.
We ran both as retained searches. We started by working with the owners on what success needed to look like on day one, at six and twelve months and beyond, then mapped the market and approached people with the right experience and the temperament for an owner-managed business. Because it was their first time hiring at this level, we also helped design the interview stages, assessment criteria and presentation formats.
Both appointments were made within four weeks, and both are now integral to the leadership team delivering the next phase of growth.
The Eaton Syalon view
[Quote from Jo: two or three sentences on what owner-managed businesses most often get wrong with a first senior hire.]
Before you start a senior search
- Write down what success looks like at twelve months before you write the job description.
- Be honest about the budget and the package; the market will test it quickly.
- Decide who is involved in the decision, and keep the process short enough to hold good candidates.
- Ask any search partner how they’ll find people who aren’t looking, and how they’ll represent your business when they do.
If you’re planning a senior appointment and want to talk it through, get in touch with Jo or Dom. A conversation first, always, before anything formal.